Compare

Comecero vs Shopify Payments

Shopify Payments is the simplest way to take cards on a Shopify store. Comecero is for the products you want on more than one gateway, with failover, subscriptions and usage billing built in.

In short

Shopify Payments processes cards inside Shopify's checkout, on one gateway, and Shopify charges 0.2% to 2% per order when you use another gateway instead. Comecero is a separate checkout that runs on your own gateways: a declined new card goes to your next gateway, and subscriptions and usage billing are built in. It runs alongside your Shopify store from a Buy button or link; it does not change Shopify's own checkout.

Updated

Compare

Comecero and Shopify Payments, side by side
Job by job.

Facts about Shopify Payments come from its own pages, linked at the bottom of this page.

What Shopify Payments and Comecero each do
JobShopify PaymentsShopify's built-in processorComecerocheckout, billing and payments
Fee for using another gateway0.2% to 2% per order, by Shopify planNo extra fee
Second gateway when a new card is declinedNot documentedYes, on Comecero checkout
Split card traffic across gatewaysOne card gateway at a timeYes, by weight
SubscriptionsThrough appsBuilt in
Usage-based billingNoYes, turned on per account
Prepaid credit drawn down by usageStore credit onlyYes, as money
Fraud checksFraud analysis, Shopify Protect on eligible ordersRules for your shop before the charge
Chargeback fee (US)$15, returned if you winSet by your gateway
Works inside Shopify's own checkoutYesNo. Runs alongside, from a button or link
Sales taxShopify Tax; remitted where Shopify manages US sales taxAdded at checkout; you file unless we are your MoR

Checked 14 Nov 2026 against each tool's public pages. If something here is out of date, tell us.

Which fits

Which one should you choose?
An honest answer.

Choose Shopify Payments if

  • You sell everything through Shopify's own checkout and want one bill
  • One gateway is enough and your decline rate is low
  • You want Shopify to manage US sales tax for you

Choose Comecero if

  • You want a second gateway to catch declined new cards on refills, bundles or a new launch
  • You want to avoid Shopify's fee for using your own gateway on those orders
  • You bill subscriptions or usage and want retries on your own schedule
  • You keep your Shopify store and add Comecero beside it

How do I move from Shopify Payments?

  1. Keep your Shopify store as it is. Nothing there has to change.
  2. Connect two or more of your own gateways in Comecero, such as Stripe and Braintree.
  3. Put a Comecero Buy button or link on the products or plans you choose.
  4. Watch declines, recoveries and revenue by source in your Comecero dashboard.

Questions

Your questions,
answered.

Can Comecero add a second gateway to Shopify's checkout?

No. Shopify allows one card gateway in its checkout, and Comecero does not change that. The second gateway works on Comecero checkout, which you add to your store with a Buy button or link.

Does Shopify charge extra if I use another gateway?

Yes. Shopify charges a fee on each order paid through a gateway other than Shopify Payments: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus, as of 14 Nov 2026. Orders on Comecero checkout are not Shopify orders, so that fee does not apply to them.

Can Comecero retry renewals my Shopify subscription app bills?

No. Those renewals bill through Shopify. Comecero retries renewals for plans billed on Comecero, on the card's own gateway.

Does Shopify Payments fail over to another gateway?

Shopify does not document automatic failover. It allows one card gateway at a time.

Sources, checked 14 Nov 2026

Prices and features change. If something here is out of date, tell us on the contact page and we will fix it.

Ready when you are

Grow in every market, on every model.

See how Comecero fits your billing, your processors and the markets you sell in. Book a demo with the team, or start free.

Your revenue review

Sample

Revenue slipping away each month

$22,700

Declined at checkout$12,400
Failed renewals$6,900
Fraud losses$2,100
Chargebacks lost$1,300

Each line comes with the fix that wins it back.